Hawaii Considers Banning Short-Term Vacation Rentals – Travel Noire

Hawaii is considering a new ban to help locals with the housing crisis. The housing crisis has been an incessant issue for years. Hawaii’s community has varying viewpoints about the thriving tourism industry on the islands. Some locals think that Hawaii needs the economic stimuli from tourism. Others consider tourists to be a nuisance to the islands and think the Hawaii ban on rentals to be a good idea.

While split views on tourism still exist in Hawaii, there is a general consensus that housing conditions have reached a boiling point. So the recent talk about a ban on short-term housing in Hawaii is one of the newest solutions to the problem. Learn more about Hawaii’s ban on rentals. 

Why Is the Ban Being Proposed?

Hawaii banned rentals for tourists, learn more about why. 
Pictured: surf boards on a tree in Hawaii
photo credit: Don Stouder

A lot of the issues contributing to the Hawaii housing crisis are related to tourism. The popular destination has had swarms of tourists visit and move to Hawaii. So, since a significant number of residents are now non-native people, the island has unbalanced housing.  

To remedy this, legislators proposed two bills after the August 8th, 2023 wildfires. The devastating fires took over one hundred people’s lives and destroyed thousands of homes. The displacement of thousands of people worsened the island’s housing crisis. 

Many Native Hawaiian residents have moved to the mainland as a result of the housing crisis. So, the bills are a last ditch effort to recover the community. At least 1,000 residents have left the island (Maui). Which suggests that locals are not reaping the benefits of the space that is available. In fact, Hawaii residents have one of the highest housing costs in the nation. It is nearly three times higher than the national average.

Sustainability is a big factor to the Hawaii ban on rentals. Both environmental and cultural sustainability are reasons why the ban may be restorative. With less home rentals filled with tourists, residents will be able to get some relief from the impact of tourism.

The bills will limit short term vacation rentals in housing built for long term or permanent housing. This would apply to condos and single family homes that are outside of the resort areas of Hawaii. But places like commercial vacation rental communities and condo hotels that are commercial properties would not be impacted. 

The potential changes to traveler’s experiences in Hawaii may alarm some visitors. But in the long run, the ban would contribute to Hawaii’s overall wellbeing. Both bills need to come to final agreements by May 3rd to get sent to the governor, for the Hawaii ban for rentals to go into effect. 

Ban’s Impact on Tourism and Locals

Learn more about how the potential ban may impact tourism.
pictured: lush green foliage in Hawii
photo credit: Tyler Casey

The potential Hawaii ban for rentals may alarm some visitors. Yet in the long run, the ban would contribute to Hawaii’s overall wellbeing. To avoid further consequences of having a dense tourism population, they may be necessary. But both bills need to come to final agreements by May 3rd to get sent to the governor. 

The housing crisis has led to a decline in the Native Hawaiian population, so the bans are an attempt to preserve the valuable local community. With tourists moving in and Hawaiians unable to afford the rising prices of living on the islands, a change is needed.

The bans should kickstart a new age where locals are prioritized. The lack of affordable housing options in Hawaii has eroded the thriving Hawaiian culture that tourists travel to enjoy. If the bills are passed, a more sustainable future is in the cards for Hawaii.